Jev annotation dispute review

Review conflicting annotation rationales

Provide the text, annotation guideline and two rationales. Inspect whether one, both or neither rationale follows the rule before resolving a labeling disagreement.

Resolve the rationale against the stated guideline.Live API
Try an example

Original synthetic input. Edit the task or evidence to make a new API request.

Source: Workflow inspiration on X

Source and example scope

The inputs, rubric and preview are original. This window demonstrates the stated decision only; it does not reproduce the source application or its measurements.

Review annotator rationales against the supplied guideline, not majority votes.

Decision rules and labels
A supportedB supportedBoth supportedNeither supportedNeed guideline
A real response from the Jev API

Edit any input to explore a different decision. No request is sent until you run it.

Your next decision

Not run yet

Choose an example or write your own input, then run it to see the ranked choices.

Results are not stored by this site. Your submitted text is processed by the API provider.

The decision

How does Jev annotation dispute review use its evidence?

Jev annotation dispute review reviews two annotation rationales against the actual text and guideline before a disagreement is resolved.

The source post describes comparing Jev classifications with the author's manual labels. Our original example reviews annotation disputes rather than calculating reliability. It does not adopt the post's spending, training-language claim or any academic coefficient.

An expected label can be wrong or incomplete. The supplied guideline determines whether one rationale fits, both fit an allowed overlap, or neither is supported. The model returns a dispute-review label and the offline consumer prints a fixed local report without replacing a dataset label.

Original Jev annotation dispute review workflow diagram showing supplied evidence, a typed decision and the local preview.
Original workflow illustration. The output is a local preview, not an executed action or source screenshot.
How it works

Try the example in four steps

Use the sample to understand the rule, then test your own input for annotation disagreement.

  1. Illustration of adding the text or evidence for a decision

    Add the information to check

    Provide the text, annotation guideline and two rationales.

  2. Illustration of defining a question and its allowed choices

    Confirm the question and labels

    Open the decision rules and keep the intended distinction between A supported, B supported, Both supported, Neither supported, Need guideline. Edit the choices only when testing your own rule.

  3. Illustration of sending one input and comparing the returned choices

    Run the decision

    Use a sample first, then try your own input. Compare the selected label with the other returned probabilities.

  4. Illustration of reviewing a result and an uncertain item before using it

    Review the next step

    Review Need guideline before using a result. The label is a decision about the supplied information, not an executed action.

Our API test

What the six original inputs returned.

What the six original inputs returned.
Original test inputObserved labelLeading probability
One rationale follows the ruleA supported100%
The other rationale follows the ruleB supported100%
An explicitly allowed overlapping caseBoth supported92%
Two unsupported rationalesNeither supported97%
No annotation guidelineNeed guideline87%
A rationale that invents a causeA supported100%
  • Measured adapter round trips: 627-1645 ms. Estimated input cost: $0.00002260-$0.00002365 per request. These observations are not a latency guarantee or invoice.

6 actual Jev API calls on October 1, 2026. Original synthetic inputs check this rubric and handoff; they do not establish held-out accuracy. Probabilities are model outputs.Verified

Understand the results

The broken-item fixture contrasts a stated problem with an unsupported positive interpretation

The broken-item fixture contrasts a stated problem with an unsupported positive interpretation.

Read the example notes

A supported concerns the supplied complaint guideline and text. It does not infer a product category or root cause. The original annotations remain visible so an adjudicator can inspect the competing rationales.

The satisfaction fixture reverses which annotator follows the rule

The satisfaction fixture reverses which annotator follows the rule. B supported checks the rationale rather than always preferring annotator A. The labels and definitions are original. A production adjudication process needs independently documented guidelines and should preserve the original disagreement.

The mixed-feedback fixture explicitly permits overlap between praise and complaint

The mixed-feedback fixture explicitly permits overlap between praise and complaint. Both supported records that the guideline can accommodate each rationale. This is different from a single-label rule whose classes are mutually exclusive. Changing that guideline would create a different question.

The color fixture supplies neither a reported problem nor explicit satisfaction

The color fixture supplies neither a reported problem nor explicit satisfaction. Neither supported prevents both annotators from inventing sentiment based on a color preference. The report does not create a replacement label; a revised annotation task would need its own defined outcome.

The no-guideline fixture lacks the rule needed to assess two conflicting labels

The no-guideline fixture lacks the rule needed to assess two conflicting labels. Need guideline preserves that gap. A familiar dataset name or a human annotator's confidence cannot substitute for the actual labeling contract in this example.

The late-delivery fixture contrasts an explicit observation with an invented product-defect cause

The late-delivery fixture contrasts an explicit observation with an invented product-defect cause.

Read the example notes

A supported follows the rule against inferred causes. Six dispute fixtures do not measure agreement or model reliability. Keep actual responses and use a separate statistical procedure for a representative labeled evaluation.

Using the result in your application

Download the exact sample requests and saved observations below.

Read the example notes

Expected labels are original fixture checks and stay outside the request sent to Jev. The observation file preserves the complete probabilities and the hash of each exact request. Editing a task, rubric or candidate requires a fresh response; a matching sample name does not make an older answer current.

Using the result in your application

The JavaScript runner makes one independent SDK request for a chosen sample ID.

Read the example notes

It reads TYPESAFE_API_KEY privately from the environment and has no automatic retry. The Python consumer operates offline: it checks the rubric, labels, unique sample identities, request hashes and valid probability distributions before selecting a fixed local preview. A tied leading result remains pending for review.

Source and example scope

The page reports measured adapter round trips and estimated input cost for the recorded calls.

Read the example notes

Those values describe these requests, not a provider latency guarantee or a billing statement. Six deliberately authored fixtures can check the stated behavior, but they do not establish accuracy on an unseen dataset. Keep disagreements and missing-input examples when testing an integration.

Runnable offline example

Replay one request and inspect the saved preview.

View the code example
Replay commands
npm install @typesafe-ai/sdk@0.6.0
# Set TYPESAFE_API_KEY privately in your shell.
node run-choice-sample.mjs samples.json a
python preview_choice_workflow_v2.py samples.json saved-api-results.json
Scope of this demo

Where does this decision fit?

Useful with explicit supplied evidence

  • Compare two supplied annotation rationales against a stated text-label guideline, preserving equally supported or unsupported interpretations. Original guideline and examples only; no agreement coefficient or academic result is reproduced.
  • Inspecting the original task and a fixed output before integrating external tools.
  • Comparing an explicit expected label with the complete recorded distribution.

Needs separate implementation or evidence

  • Inferring facts absent from the supplied input.
  • Treating a semantic selection as authorization to act.
  • Executing an external action or generalizing six fixtures into an accuracy claim.
Example FAQ

Questions about this original decision workflow.

Keep relevance, compliance and execution separate.

What does annotation dispute review compare?

It compares the two supplied rationales with the exact guideline and text.

Does the model calculate an agreement coefficient?

No. It performs one bounded semantic review and no agreement arithmetic.

Is the human annotation always the correct reference?

The rubric follows the supplied guideline and evidence rather than annotator identity.

When can both rationales be supported?

Only when the supplied guideline explicitly allows the overlapping interpretation.

Does the report overwrite dataset labels?

No. It is a fixed local preview and retains the original annotations.

Try a task from your own workflow

Change the supplied task or evidence here, then inspect the live response. Playground supports another explicit decision.