{
  "kind": "original-bounded-choice-workflow",
  "version": 1,
  "scope": "Interpret whether insulting words are a directed attack, clearly reported or analyzed language, criticism of work or an ambiguous quotation. Propose a fixed text moderation review step without enforcement.",
  "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
  "choices": [
    "Directed insult",
    "Reported quotation",
    "Neutral criticism",
    "Need context"
  ],
  "actions": {
    "Directed insult": {
      "action": "review_directed_insult",
      "payload": {
        "contextLabel": "Directed insult",
        "enforcementPerformed": false
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Reported quotation": {
      "action": "retain_report_or_analysis",
      "payload": {
        "contextLabel": "Reported quotation",
        "enforcementPerformed": false
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Neutral criticism": {
      "action": "retain_work_criticism",
      "payload": {
        "contextLabel": "Neutral criticism",
        "enforcementPerformed": false
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Need context": {
      "action": "request_conversation_context",
      "payload": {
        "contextLabel": "Need context",
        "enforcementPerformed": false
      },
      "pending": true
    }
  },
  "samples": [
    {
      "id": "direct",
      "label": "An insult aimed at a participant",
      "expected": "Directed insult",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"Alex, you are an idiot. That is why nobody should listen to you.\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"The speaker addresses participant Alex in a discussion.\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "reported",
      "label": "A quoted insult reported to moderators",
      "expected": "Reported quotation",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"I need to report what someone wrote to me: \\\"you are an idiot.\\\" I disagree with that attack and want a moderator to review it.\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"A participant submits a report about an earlier message. The earlier author and full thread are not supplied.\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "work-critique",
      "label": "Criticism of the implementation",
      "expected": "Neutral criticism",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"This implementation discards errors before the caller can inspect them. I think the error-handling design needs revision.\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"A code review discusses error handling. No personal statement about the author appears.\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "quote-only",
      "label": "An isolated quote without purpose",
      "expected": "Need context",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"\\\"You are an idiot.\\\"\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "weaponized-quote",
      "label": "Quotation marks used to insult",
      "expected": "Directed insult",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"Alex, as everyone can see, \\\"you are an idiot.\\\" I am saying that about you now.\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"The speaker addresses Alex and explicitly adopts the quoted sentence.\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "analysis",
      "label": "A discussion of insulting language",
      "expected": "Reported quotation",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Review the use of the quoted or critical language under the supplied moderation rule.\",\n  \"message\": \"In this moderation example, the sentence \\\"you are an idiot\\\" is a personal attack. We are analyzing the phrase, not directing it at anyone here.\",\n  \"surroundingContext\": \"An educational discussion analyzes an example of insulting language.\"\n}",
        "question": "Read message and surroundingContext under this narrow rule. Directed insult: speaker uses a personal insult against another participant, including quoted wording used to attack. Reported quotation: speaker clearly reports or analyzes an insult without endorsing it. Neutral criticism: critiques an idea, behavior or work without attacking a person. Need context: purpose or target cannot be established. Quotation marks alone are not an exemption. No bans, identity judgments or legal conclusions.",
        "choices": [
          "Directed insult",
          "Reported quotation",
          "Neutral criticism",
          "Need context"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "consumer": "preview_choice_workflow_v2.py"
}
