{
  "kind": "original-bounded-choice-workflow",
  "version": 1,
  "scope": "Interpret a security claim against its supplied test observations, separating a described observed effect, a completed failed attempt and evidence not supplied; print a pending local evidence-status packet. No probing, finding approval or severity calculation.",
  "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
  "choices": [
    "Observed effect",
    "Attempt failed",
    "Need evidence"
  ],
  "actions": {
    "Observed effect": {
      "action": "preview_finding_evidence",
      "payload": {
        "evidenceStatus": "Observed effect",
        "findingApproved": false
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Attempt failed": {
      "action": "preview_finding_evidence",
      "payload": {
        "evidenceStatus": "Attempt failed",
        "findingApproved": false
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Need evidence": {
      "action": "preview_finding_evidence",
      "payload": {
        "evidenceStatus": "Need evidence",
        "findingApproved": false
      },
      "pending": true
    }
  },
  "samples": [
    {
      "id": "cross-account-record",
      "label": "A record from another account",
      "expected": "Observed effect",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: a signed-in user can read another account invoice. Test notes: in our synthetic test, user Mira owns invoice A. Mira requested invoice B owned by Noor; the response contained Noor's invoice number and address. Ownership was checked in the supplied fixture manifest.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "access-denied",
      "label": "The same request was denied",
      "expected": "Attempt failed",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: a signed-in user can read another account invoice. Test notes: Mira requested Noor's invoice; the completed request returned access denied and no invoice content. The test account and invoice ownership were checked.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "scanner-only",
      "label": "A scanner label without an observation",
      "expected": "Need evidence",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: a signed-in user can read another account invoice. Test notes: a scanner marked the invoice route as a possible access-control issue. No request or response from a cross-account test is available.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "public-help",
      "label": "A public page returned successfully",
      "expected": "Need evidence",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: a signed-in user can read another account invoice. Test notes: a request to the public help page returned a help article. No invoice route was tested.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "escaped-markup",
      "label": "Submitted markup displayed as plain text",
      "expected": "Attempt failed",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: profile input executes a script in another user's browser. Test notes: the authorized synthetic test submitted markup; the viewer displayed escaped plain text. The browser observation explicitly records that no script executed.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "narrative-only",
      "label": "A conclusion without its evidence",
      "expected": "Need evidence",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Claim: resetting a password revokes all old sessions. Test notes: the author writes \\\"the sessions must have been revoked\\\" but provides no check of an old session after the reset.\"\n}",
        "question": "Review the security claim against supplied test notes. Observed effect: notes describe the claimed unauthorized behavior and a matching observed result. Attempt failed: a completed relevant test denies or prevents that effect. Need evidence: only a hypothesis, scanner label, unrelated response, ambiguous outcome or missing observation is supplied. Judge supplied evidence only; do not run tests, approve a finding, calculate severity or infer system safety.",
        "choices": [
          "Observed effect",
          "Attempt failed",
          "Need evidence"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "consumer": "preview_choice_workflow_v2.py"
}
