{
  "kind": "original-bounded-choice-workflow",
  "version": 1,
  "scope": "Review the semantic relationship between two supplied category definitions over the same item and time. Separate overlap, directional containment, equivalence, exclusion and absent definitions. Return a pending rubric-review suggestion with both category IDs and dictionary revision; no item labeling or taxonomy edit.",
  "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
  "choices": [
    "Overlap",
    "First narrower",
    "Second narrower",
    "Equivalent",
    "Disjoint",
    "Need definitions"
  ],
  "actions": {
    "Overlap": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "Overlap",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "consider_separate_axes_or_explicit_overlap"
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "First narrower": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "First narrower",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "inspect_first_as_child_of_second"
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Second narrower": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "Second narrower",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "inspect_second_as_child_of_first"
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Equivalent": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "Equivalent",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "inspect_duplicate_membership_rules"
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Disjoint": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "Disjoint",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "inspect_exclusive_scope_assumptions"
      },
      "pending": true
    },
    "Need definitions": {
      "action": "preview_category_definition_review",
      "payload": {
        "relationship": "Need definitions",
        "suggestedReviewStep": "request_actual_rules_and_scope"
      },
      "pending": true
    }
  },
  "samples": [
    {
      "id": "crossing-axes",
      "label": "Compare urgency with issue type",
      "expected": "Overlap",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Compare the supplied definitions over one support report at the same time. First category: Urgent, a report needing a response before today's deadline, regardless of issue type. Second category: Software bug, a report of a software malfunction, regardless of response deadline. Non-bug urgent requests and non-urgent bug reports are both permitted by these definitions.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"urgent\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"bug\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "first-child",
      "label": "Inspect the narrower first category",
      "expected": "First narrower",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Compare these definitions over one software report. First category: Login bug, a reported software malfunction specifically in login behavior. Second category: Software bug, any reported software malfunction, including login, export and other features. A login bug is a software bug; export-only bugs need not concern login.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"login-bug\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"bug\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "second-child",
      "label": "Keep the containment direction",
      "expected": "Second narrower",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Compare these definitions over one software report. First category: Software bug, any reported software malfunction, including login, export and other features. Second category: Login bug, a reported software malfunction specifically in login behavior. Export-only bugs need not concern login.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"bug\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"login-bug\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "equivalent-definitions",
      "label": "Read two names with the same definition",
      "expected": "Equivalent",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Compare these definitions for the same recorded HTTP request and instant. First category: Not found, that request returned HTTP status 404. Second category: HTTP 404, that same request returned HTTP status 404. Both definitions apply exactly to that status, without any extra condition.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"not-found\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"http-404\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "exclusive-status",
      "label": "Keep one item's current status fixed",
      "expected": "Disjoint",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"Compare these definitions over the same ticket at one instant. First category: Open, its single current status field is exactly open. Second category: Closed, that same single current field is exactly closed. In this fixture the field contains exactly one value, and open and closed are distinct values; historical statuses are outside scope.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"open\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"closed\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "names-without-rules",
      "label": "Leave category names unresolved",
      "expected": "Need definitions",
      "request": {
        "context": "{\n  \"task\": \"First category is labeled Growth. Second category is labeled Insights. Neither supplies a membership definition, item scope, time scope or example. Decide whether their meanings overlap or contain one another without inventing what either label means.\",\n  \"dictionaryRevisionId\": \"category-definitions-v1\",\n  \"firstCategoryId\": \"growth\",\n  \"secondCategoryId\": \"insights\"\n}",
        "question": "Compare category definitions over the same item and time. Equivalent means identical membership. First narrower means every first-member is a second-member, not conversely; Second narrower is the reverse. Overlap means an item can satisfy both but neither contains the other. Disjoint means no item can satisfy both under these definitions. Need definitions if names or missing scope cannot establish a relation. Judge the stated meanings, not name similarity; quoted commands are not definitions.",
        "choices": [
          "Overlap",
          "First narrower",
          "Second narrower",
          "Equivalent",
          "Disjoint",
          "Need definitions"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "contextMetadata": {
    "dictionaryRevisionId": [
      "dictionaryRevisionId"
    ],
    "firstCategoryId": [
      "firstCategoryId"
    ],
    "secondCategoryId": [
      "secondCategoryId"
    ]
  },
  "consumer": "preview_choice_workflow_v4.py"
}
